The Notre Dame football team has departed Boston, celebrated Thanksgiving on campus, and will continue its cross-country journey to Palo Alto, CA to play the Stanford Cardinal in the regular season finale on Saturday evening. The Irish have fallen to sixth in the current playoff rankings by virtue of an unimpressive 19-16 victory over 3-8 Boston College that was marred by five costly turnovers and injuries to two more key starters. In order to complete its mission of participating in the college football playoff, Notre Dame must play a solid, 60-minute game and defeat a quality opponent on the road. Stanford, of course, has other ideas and at 9-2 the Cardinal still harbor faint playoff dreams of their own. Fox will televise the game nationally beginning at 7:30 PM Eastern time.
Following a 16-6 loss to Northwestern in its season opener, Stanford has scored at least 30 points in each subsequent game. Senior quarterback Kevin Hogan directs the attack, and tailback/kick returner Christian McCaffrey has Heisman-quality numbers for total offense with over 2800 combined yards, which is by far the best in the nation. Coach David Shaw is 51-14 in his fifth year at the helm of his alma mater, and the Cardinal will play for the PAC-12 championship next weekend.
The Irish continue to look for able bodies in light of the season-long injury curse that has tested their depth and their will. Last week, C.J. Prosise and KeiVarae Russell became the eighth and ninth starters to suffer season ending injuries. It’s safe to say that no other playoff contender has experienced similar misfortune, but the question is whether it will catch up to Notre Dame this weekend as the team has been running on fumes throughout a difficult November.
Stanford has been much more fortunate on the injury front as its starting lineup has been intact for most of the season. This week, fullback Daniel Marx is out while senior cornerback Ronnie Harris is questionable. Harris is the team’s best cover man and would be missed if his injured ankle keeps him on the sideline.
NOTRE DAME’S OFFENSE vs. STANFORD’S DEFENSE
The Cardinal have several new faces on their 3-4 defense this year, but senior linebackers Blake Martinez and Kevin Anderson are the mainstays. Martinez leads the team in tackles by a wide margin and Anderson is an effective pass rusher from his outside position. The revamped front line features end Brennan Scarlett, a graduate transfer from rival Cal, nose tackle Solomon Thomas and end Aziz Shittu. The group is slightly above average against the run but has surrendered more yards and points this season than the last few seasons where they were among the nation’s best.
The secondary, particularly without Harris, may be vulnerable. Conference opponents have moved the ball well through the air against Stanford, but the offense has managed to outscore most of them. The Cardinal also tighten up in the red zone and quite often force teams to settle for field goals. Notre Dame must capitalize on its opportunities in these situations, which will require a 180 degree turnaround from last week.
Ball security and turnovers plagued the Irish against BC, but Stanford has forced just ten miscues all season and is not a team that blitzes frequently or is known to pressure the quarterback. Notre Dame can take advantage of certain matchups in the passing game, but only if star players such as Will Fuller catch the ball when it is thrown their way. In the running game, the Irish will enjoy a size advantage over the Cardinal in clearing a path for Josh Adams. The key to success may be the ability of Notre Dame’s center and guards to fire out and block Martinez and Anderson.
Stanford is not very deep up front, so the Irish should not be reluctant to assert themselves physically. Quarterback DeShone Kizer will carry the ball a few times as well, as the team must pull out all the stops to come away with a victory in what is essentially an elimination game. Although there is no guarantee of a spot in the final four should Notre Dame prevail, other games this weekend are bound to produce a few surprises and a potential opening for the Irish should they take care of business in Palo Alto.
STANFORD’S OFFENSE vs. NOTRE DAME’S DEFENSE
Hogan has been his usual efficient self this year with a 67% completion rate and the ability to pull the ball down and run for first downs when they are needed most. He has speed on the edge at receiver with senior Michael Rector, a solid possession wideout in Devin Cajuste, and a pair of productive tight ends in Austin Hooper and Greg Taboada. Notre Dame will have to find a replacement for Russell at cornerback. The candidates are Devin Butler, Nick Watkins and freshman Nick Coleman. Whomever gets the starting nod will be a marked man all night.
Hogan’s favorite target is the workhorse McCaffrey, as the Cardinal simply try to get the ball to him in space. In addition to his 1546 yards rushing, he is the team’s leading pass catcher and frequently turns short throws to the flat into big plays. Stanford also mixes in other talented tailbacks including Barry Sanders, Jr. and freshman Bryce Love. The latter is fast and extremely dangerous on jet sweeps and in the open field. The short yardage back is Remound Wright, who runs behind a jumbo package of lead blockers consisting of two or three additional 300 pound linemen.
The left side of the Cardinal offensive line is manned by a pair of stellar seniors, tackle Kyle Murphy and guard Josh Garnett. Sophomore right tackle Casey Tucker is the lone non-senior up front for Stanford, who is first in the country in time of possession at more than 35 minutes per game. It’s easy to understand this level of dominance when you note that this offense converts an impressive 50% of its third downs.
The Cardinal offense is not particularly deceptive, but they rely on the decision-making of Hogan, great balance, and the athletic ability of McCaffrey to make extraordinary plays or draw the attention of the defense away from their other threats. Once in the red zone, Hogan frequently looks for Hooper and Taboada in mismatches against smaller defensive backs. This is a quality offense that will give the Irish fits if they are not very disciplined and tackle crisply.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Kicker Conrad Ukropina has been exemplary for Stanford this season, hitting on 14 of 16 field goal attempts and showing excellent range. Punter Alex Robinson’s statistics are average and the coverage units are solid. McCaffrey is always a threat to generate a big play, and he scored on a 98-yard kick return just last week.
Notre Dame continues to benefit from strong performances by its specialists, Justin Yoon and Tyler Newsome, but the return teams have consistently failed to generate many yards. C.J. Sanders was replaced by Fuller on punt returns last week due to shakiness that nearly resulted in disaster.
SUMMARY
The Irish and Cardinal are capable of putting bunches of points on the board but need to protect defenses that can be shaky at times. The winning team will outperform the other in the usual situations: red zone efficiency, breaking tackles that turn five yard plays into 30 yard gains, turnovers, and dropped passes. Kizer’s miscues against Boston College have been dissected during the past week, but Hogan fumbled twice in the fourth quarter to give away Stanford’s game against Oregon a fortnight ago.
Both teams have strong offensive lines and quarterbacks that can run as well as pass. There are highly skilled and explosive players at running back and receiver on both sides. The Cardinal utilize the tight end in the passing game quite extensively while the Irish employ them mainly for blocking. Notre Dame’s defensive line has an edge in talent but Stanford’s linebackers as a unit are better tacklers in space than their Irish counterparts other than Jaylon Smith. Each secondary has vulnerabilities, but when the Irish make a mistake it usually results in seven points for the opponent.
Here are a few questions that will shed light on the outcome:
Which quarterback will perform best under pressure?
Will McCaffrey advance his Heisman campaign at Notre Dame’s expense?
Which star linebacker, Jaylon Smith or Blake Martinez, will be a difference maker?
Can Will Fuller bounce back and make the clutch receptions for the Irish?
Which team’s depleted secondary can rise to the occasion?
Which offense will convert its red zone opportunities?
Can Notre Dame make a compelling statement to the playoff selection committee?
PREDICTION
The Irish have more top end talent, but star players like Sheldon Day, Ronnie Stanley, Nick Martin, Max Redfield, Fuller, Smith and Kizer must each play well to overcome the more methodical but efficient Cardinal. Notre Dame has stopped itself in scoring territory far too often recently with turnovers, poor execution and questionably play calling. The uneven performances in last two games reflect a team that is out of gas, and Kizer is returning to Earth after heroics against Virginia and Temple. Hogan’s experience will be a factor on Saturday, and the weight of prior injuries will finally prove to be too much for the Irish to overcome.
STANFORD 34 NOTRE DAME 27
Brendenomalley says:
This team has performed well considering all the injuries, but Kizer seems to have lost a little confidence in the last couple of weeks. We have struggled to stop the straight ahead attack we will see Saturday. 10-2 will be a fine achievement considering. Winning a major bowl against a strong opponent would cap off the season.
Mark says:
Thanks for the thorough and honest assessment. Well done. That being said, both you and I hope you are wrong!
Go Irish!!!
ccb says:
Irish wake up in 4th quarter after trailing at halftime.
ND 41
Stanford 31
Scott says:
I like your assessment. Irish 45, Stanford 28.
Pc says:
I am very concerned about our defense and our ability to deal with their smash mouth approach but I have sky high confidence in Kizer and feel the offense awakens big time.
Irish 38-34
Jake in California says:
Vannie,
Happy Thanksgiving.. Thank you for all that you do!! You’re the best!!
And yes, Irish out of gas and Kelly is out of ideas.. Stanford lays the wood to us:
Stanford 39
ND 14
Pc says:
Really…39-14??? That’s amusing
Jake in California says:
Pc,
Yes, I don’t think it will close.. Stanford is playing great football right now and McCaffrey
will be too much for us.. Cardinal will win big..
dan says:
Kelly is unable to optimally inspire the team and to win the big ones. The facemask penalty during Stanford’s last drive is the perfect example.
Brian M says:
If ND would have scored in all 3 of the red zone possessions in the first half last week instead of turning it over the game would not have been close. The offense moved the ball but it is a big let down when you turn the ball over each time in the red zone. They had 445 yards offense, but could not hold onto the ball. Kizer had a bad game but he is a freshman and his Ted to to ration is very comparable to Hogan of Stanford. I think Kizer will do better but the main thing is his surrounding cast. Adams has to hold onto the ball and Fuller has to step up and make the catches this game! Go Irish!
canuck75 says:
Kelly has proven to rise to the occasion in similar situations. I am hopeful that they will unleash Fuller
this week. And the D will finally play a complete game.
ND 31 Stanford 17.
dan says:
Kelly is the weak link in ND’s football program with he and his coaching staff’s inept play calling. It was all very evident in the loss to Stanford. A few great big plays but in the trenches very uninspiring compared to the Cardinal.
NDBonecrusher says:
To quote the dude in Apollo 13: I believe we’re about to see our finest hour. This is a classic ND Moment!
mrm says:
I have that same gut feeling Bonecrusher. Go Irish!!
Austinirish says:
About time for the Irish to play a good, mistake-free game. Irish 27 Tree 24.
Josh says:
Notre Dame is one of the most resilient teams in college football they have overcome adversity on a number of different occasions this year and I find this game to be no different after losing Khavari Russell for the year. My vote this year is BRIAN KELLY for COACH OF THE YEAR! the Irish win at Stanford 34-24 go Irish
dan says:
What a joke!
irishawk50 says:
It’s too bad that even if the Irish beat Stanford they may not make the playoffs because they didn’t crush Wake Forest and BC. The #6 ranking is probably deserved because they didn’t take care of business. I hope they defeat Stanford and make it to the playoffs, but all things considered they did better than I expected this year especially considering all the injuries. Go Irish!
Jack Studer says:
If th;is was a home game we might have a chance. If we don’t get blown out by the Cardinal we should get a decent bowl game out of the season. Better not to get embarrassed like the Alabama debacle and look forward to next year (again) with some confidence. Anyone sort of wondering about the quarterback position next fall?
NDBonecrusher says:
Jack I’m not thinking about that yet. We still have 3 games to play this season.
That’s right. THREE. I would rather be a fool of an optimist than sell these guys short after everything they have overcome. Irish win thanks to Justin Yoon’s toe. ND 38 Stan 35.
bocceman2 says:
Everyone forgives Kizer because he is a freshman. Does anyone remember Cardale Jones last year, third stringer inserted in last game of regular season and took OSU to the promised land? Kelly has not improved this offense or Kizer since Virginia game. In fact, name one season under Kelly where the team actually improved from game 1 to game 12. 10-2 is ok but don’t see ND rising to top under Kelly. Mike, do you have Kelly turn over vs take away stats under Kelly? Also red zone efficiency under Kelly?
dan says:
Look at ND performance in the red zone today. Pitiful. We can do better than Kelly but 99% of the fans and the administration will stick to him like glue. I hope both Kelly and Les Miles are email pals. Both are a brick shy of a load when it comes to coaching big league teams.
Ellen says:
Go Irish. I hope they prove all skeptics wrong and beat Stanford then the playoff committee will have to face the music and put ND in the playoff instead of a Oklahoma team. What was so impressive about Oklahome beating Baylor by 1point at home and Baylor missing 4starters! The committee cannot explain that one. Love ND.
Ellen says:
Sorry about last comment. I meant to say TCU losing to Oklahoma. Got caught up in emotion.
Noel says:
It will be a 3 point game either way. Hopefully Jaylon will be McCaffery’s shadow all day. Joe Scmitt wil need close up the gap in the middle and make the tackles he’s been missing all year. This game will come down to who ever makes the play in the last 2 minutes of the 4th. Hopefully I’m wrong and the Irish light up the Stanford secondary and close the deal.
JTW says:
Great article, as they are every week must-reads.
One big question to add- Will ND defense stop big run/run after catch plays?
I’m going short this time- ND 20, Trees 17, with ND goal line stand to win.
GOND88 says:
Vannie took the words out of my mouth. The Irish are running out of gas and it seems confidence, too. They’ll put some point on the board but will always be a step and a touchdown behind the cardinal in this one. It’s a good thing the Stanford defense is of old is a shell of its former self.
Mope says:
I just enjoy the fact that David Shaw isnt the head football coach, he is the Bradford M. Freeman Director of Fottball. Irish by 4, with both teams scoring over 24. A win, but not enough to break into the final four.
Fulkerson's Ghost says:
If you give the Irish a chance to lose, they usually will. They didn’t belong in the playoff conversation, so this will finally put that delusion to rest.
NDBonecrusher says:
Ugh. Right score, wrong sides. The boys got heart, no mistake. Will get a nice bowl, but no playoffs.
irishhawk50 says:
Trying to remember if the secondary broke up any passes? Bend but don’t break with a 3 man rush didn’t do much in the end. Could have had all 11 in the secondary still couldn’t break up a pass. Nice wrap up by Butler on the 12 yard line of that score. Couldn’t have asked any more of the offense. Front seven stopped the run. Did I mention the secondary…..
Chuckie says:
Lost by one point. They fought the good fight, hobbled with injuries, and almost completed the mission. The valiant Irish will be back.
Joe B says:
Thought it was a mistake to call timeout on that first and goal and not letting any clock run, and it turned out to be the killer. That being said, a playoff caliber team can keep an average offense from going 50 yards in 20 seconds. Should get a nice bowl (please don’t let it be OSU), and should be top 5 entering next year with all the talent coming back. Hopefully the safeties use the offseason to learn how to read play action and spot a trick play for once.
Viktor racz says:
Someone please fire that idiot Van Gorder. 2 years without any semblance of a defense
Terry says:
What else did you expect? The fumble at the end of the first half was HORRIBLE! Cost them the game and was pathetic. What was also pathetic was so many stalled drives against a defense that you are faster and stronger than. What confuses me is how hard the passing game is for a spread offense that has a good running game, to this day BK can’t coach a QB! The 2-point conversion was a joke, instead of keeping the play alive he threw it away, lol. What gets me the most is the fact that Kizer’s head is so confused he doesn’t know when to scramble or throw it away, even how to scramble! He used to stay in the pocket, but after the BC game, I think he lost a lot of his confidence. He definitely needs to hit the weight room harder, not be able to go through a DB that he outweighed by 25 pounds on the last offensive play. It would have been better had they not counted the TD after the replay, and ND had scamble to the line and run a play with 20 seconds left, then gotten stopped and scored with 15 or 10. What really disappointed me was that they couldn’t get any pressure on the QB. The linebackers were supposed to be good, but their blitzes were so weak and readable and ineffective, plus the D-Line should have gotten more pressure, especially when 5-6 men were rushing. The missed tackle for a loss on Standford’s pass on the right flat was a complete choke, the receiver didn’t even hardly move, the DB just had no confidence and didn’t wrap-up. Typical ND game from the past 20 years, the players are very nonchalant; I don’t think they trust BK because he doesn’t instill confidence in them so they buy in and pay attention to detail; not one ND QB over his futile reign has really looked sharp, and once again ND has not one a big game.